Assigned peer-reviews

Assigned peer-reviews

by Bentley Oakes -
Number of replies: 2

Hi everyone,

For the peer-reviews of the paper reviews, they should now be set up. My apologies if I wasn't clear about the process. Everyone should be set to review one other review, and be reviewed by someone. Let me know if there's an issue.

You can start your peer review starting at noon tomorrow. (Reasons for the delay: a) Moodle doesn't let me assign reviews until people have submitted files. and b) Moodle can either accept submissions, or let you peer review. Not both...)

Please be kind in your review, and leave a few positive and/or negative sentences on each criteria for the person's review. Also, I tried to match people's topics, but you may have a paper out of your field. That's good! It's practice for when you have to rely on someone else's expertise about a paper and their recommendation.

Please let me know if you have any comments or questions. I'm also working on marking the summaries, but this may be a few days yet.

Happy Thanksgiving weekend!

Bentley

In reply to Bentley Oakes

Re: Assigned peer-reviews

by Nour Shaheen -
Hello Professor,

I am wondering if we need to also fill out the overleaf template with our comments and submit that, or should we only fill out the peer-review aspects/comments in moodle?

Thanks in advance!
In reply to Nour Shaheen

Re: Assigned peer-reviews

by Bentley Oakes -
Hi Nour,

Thanks for the question. The peer-review is performed only through Moodle. Please let me know if you have trouble with it.

Bentley